From the Desk of the Publisher and Managing Editor

October 2001     Vol 5  No 3     Reg No.SS-346


Publisher & Managing Editor:
Ikram-ul-Majeed Sehgal

Chief Patron
Air Marshal (Retd)

Mohammad Asghar Khan

Patrons
Lt Gen (Retd) SF Lodi

Brig (Retd)TH Siddiqi
Lt Gen (Retd) Imtiaz Waraich

Board of Editorial Advisors
Ardeshir Cowasjee

Arif Nizami
Ms Nasim Zehra
Humayun Gauhar
Ambassador (Retd) Afzal Mahmood

Brig (Retd) Saeed Ismat, SJ

Editorial Consultant
Col (Retd) Nusrat Ullah

Panel of Contributing Editors
Air Marshal (Retd) Ayaz A. Khan

Vice Adm (Retd) IF Quadir
Dr Shireen Mazari

Panel of Columnists
Col (Retd) EAS Bokhari
Col (Retd) Abdul Qayyum
Dr. Matiur Rahman
Ms Amina Jilani
Capt (Retd) A.A. Jilani
A. H. Amin

Graphic Designer
Rizwan Alam Khan

Internet Coordinator
Ms Perveen Akhter, EVP

Marketing & Sales
Syed Tauseef  Muhammad Ali
Tel: (021) 5843421, 5843502-9

Karachi
Akber Moiz, VP Coordination
Naushad Alam, AVP Marketing
Rahil Tariq, Advertisement Manager

Lahore
Kamran Ahmed Chohan, Capt (Retd), VP Coordination
Azizullah Goheer, AVP Marketing
Tel: (042) 6313759

Islamabad
Muhammad Jawad Malik, AVP Marketing
M. Hussain Akbar, AVP Marketing
Tel: (051) 2828351, 2826674

Circulation & Accounts
Ms Perveen Akhter, EVP

Cover Design
Khurram Mahmood

Printing Manager

Tariq Jamal

Bureau Chief Lahore
Dr. Mansoor Ahmed Khan
Tel: (042) 6313759, Fax: (042) 6360236

Bureau Chief Rawalpindi/Islamabad
Qamar Bhatti Tel: (051) 2875165
Ms Anwara Shaikh, EVP Public Relations
Tel: (051) 2823851, 2826674

Dubai Representative
Al-Hurriya Advertising

Akhtar Alam
Director Marketing
Tel : (+9714) 2634680, Fax : (042) 6360236

Printed at Pathfinder Printing Press. Under the steps Hocley Stadium, Phase 5, Defence Housing Authority Karachi.

Creative Publicity is handled by
DYNAVIS (Pvt) Ltd
Tel 5843502, 578798, 5863920 Fax:(021) 5863924
Lahore: (042) 6360236
Islamabad: (051) 277683, 815168

 

Dear Readers,

September 2001 has been an amazing month for Pakistan and Pakistan’s supreme leader, Pervez Musharraf. After Agra, everything has gone right for the President, the geo-political somersault that has brought Pakistan out of the cold and back on world centre stage has been a remarkable turnaround of fortunes. The terrorists who committed the horrific act on the twin towers of the World Trade Centre (WTC) in New York had no idea what forces they were unleashing and how many countless millions of lives they were affecting. Not only has Pakistan suddenly become a darling of the west, even Tony Blair came calling on the dictator the British once vowed they would never have any truck with because he had overthrown a democratically elected government. Living on the edge of economic bankruptcy, which we have been warding of successfully for the past 2 years, we have been saved by the bell. With money pouring in for debt relief, economic assistance, humanitarian  aid and what have you, etc, Pakistan will be a boomtown itself in contrast to the  rest of the world undergoing a sustained recession. However, whether the benefits will flow to the common man depends upon how much control Musharraf and his men can exercise over the human vultures who inhabit Pakistan in good numbers and who have an inherent capacity to siphon off public funds. Till 1981, Gen Ziaul Haq and his close associate, Gen Akhtar Abdur Rahman, remained what they were, good army officers from middle class backgrounds and comfortable in middle class living. Once CIA money, along with other funds from many other sources, started to pour in, their sons overnight became business geniuses who became overnight millionaires many times over doing in businesses yet unstated, an amazing coincidence with the CIA funds coming from unmarked accounts. One requests Pervez Musharraf that in putting “Pakistan first” he would avoid such coincidences being repeated to the detriment of the people of the country. Moreover, if he avoids being compromised himself, storing away foreign funds in his pockets (and thus prone to blackmail by the other negotiating party in country-to-country talks), he will certainly get a far better deal for Pakistan than his 80s predecessors did. Pervez Musharraf is a man of destiny and we have great hopes in his leadership as expressed in my article written for THE NATION entitled “LEADING FROM THE FRONT” which I am taking the liberty of re-producing with thanks.

Most Pakistanis have been aware since Agra that Pervez Musharraf’s boots were meant for walking on the world stage. The man who leads the country and the moment have come together seamlessly in a crisis, comfortable with his destiny and having the inherent ability to seize opportunity whenever and in whichever form it comes. Given Hobson’s Choice, damned if he will, damned if he won’t, the Pakistani leader went with his gut instinct, proving the description of leader who appears once in a blue moon, to quote Lord Wavell’s, “having the unerring tenth instinct, like a kingfisher flashing across the surface of a pond”. Pervez Musharraf, General of the Army, President by default, but on merit Chief of Army Staff (COAS) and Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee (JCSC), did not vacillate, did not drag his feet as he followed Richard Nixon’s advice in not “debating a point to death”. With the country facing its gravest crisis since 1971, Musharraf took the hard but unpopular road in doing what is morally right. The recent terrorist attack in the US cannot be justified by any civilized society. Anybody who does so qualifies for being stark, raving mad.

The sound of a bullet is a great equalizer, it separates the men from the boys. The crisis of the magnitude that Pakistan is facing is the acid test of the character of our leadership. Faced with the rank injustices of the Radcliffe Award in 1947, the lawyer within our Quaid urged a legal battle, Choosing the race against time (now or never!) he went against the thrust of his personality and training to accept a “truncated, moth-eaten Pakistan” rather than no Pakistan at all. Musharraf put at stake his person, his reputation and credibility rather than put the nation to unlimited risk. The media propaganda has been so intense, any indecision or delay would have had long term adverse consequences for our very existence as a nation, (very quickly) Musharraf decided that notwithstanding the emotional display in the streets, overwhelming logic demanded that Pakistan came first. Going against terrorism is contrary to vocal public perception, not only in the streets but in some of the drawing rooms of the elite and educated (who should know better), Musharaf has taken a calculated risk with raw courage. An uncompromising fighter against the Russian occupation of Afghanistan, wealthy Osama bin Laden may have captivated the public imagination but what manner of man is ready to bring misery to millions so that he himself can survive? Even now hundreds of thousands of apprehensive Afghans, mainlywomen and children, are walking in many columns towards safety in Pakistan. The Taliban are being very loyal to him, is he being loyal to the hapless Afghans? Circumstantial evidence seems to be building into a solid case against Bin Laden. While there is no “smoking gun” making the case watertight, Osama is a self-confessed terrorist who has to be brought to justice. The long years of war have denuded Afghanistan virtually of all its assets and a fair amount of its population. Callous though it may seem, the Afghans are conditioned to it. Our people have no idea of the privations such international isolation would bring. Pakistan has everything to lose in all senses of the word, why should we render this sacrifice?

The demands the US Government. made of Pakistan were unambiguous, viz (1) are you with the USA or not? If the answer is “yes” then (2) share intelligence information about Afghanistan and Osama bin Laden (3) allow free use of airspace (4) block fuel supplies to Afghanistan and (5) provide such logistics support for any impending military operation an “as required basis”. An outright “no” would have meant that we were aligned with Afghanistan against the US, that would have been not only illogical but catastrophic. While the great silent majority of Pakistanis are fond of Americans, they have been extremely disappointed with the US; acclaiming Pakistan at one time as the cornerstone of US policy in the region, the US had abandoned Pakistan. Technically, that is true! To add insult to assumed injury, the US turned to India, long opposed to the US on all counts till lately, as its principal ally and partner in the region, militarily and politically, not in any anti-Pakistan alliance but more to contain China. A “no” answer would have been to Pakistan’s eternal detriment, the very first assault (cruise missiles, air attacks) targeting our strategic nuclear assets, India would have loved to be the instrument of our destruction.

Diplomatically Afghanistan is isolated; physically it will be when Pakistan’s borders with it are closed. Militarily the US can, viz (1) repeat the 1998 attack by cruise missiles on known Taliban concentrations and rest areas (2) declare Afghanistan a no-fly zone a la Iraq and interdict any air or surface movement by the use of airpower from aircraft carriers in the Gulf and from Pakistan, Tajikistan, etc. (3) establish forward staging bases in Pakistan, Tajikistan, etc to carry out airmobile operations (4) support with airpower a Northern Alliance grand alliance offensive against Kabul (5) attempt a full-fledged ground invasion of Afghanistan with a multi-lateral force, and lastly (6) carry out tactical nuclear strikes. A history of sorry invaders, viz British, Russian, etc compels military planners to exorcise from their minds any thoughts of a major ground invasion in Afghanistan but a Northern Alliance offensive is definitely on the cards, imminent in the next few weeks so as to expel the Taliban from Kabul before winter. The US does not need tactical nuclear strikes, that is out. A combination of the first three options is possible i.e. cruise missiles to knock out any Taliban military potential, combat air patrols night and day over Afghanistan to restrict all movement within the country, using cluster bombs and fuel air explosives at Taliban concentrations, and lastly, to conduct airmobile “hit and snatch” raids inside Afghanistan using forward logistics bases. Ormara would certainly be the major naval staging port, at least two (or even three) logistic bases being established in Balochistan Province a 100 - 150 miles or so from the Afghan Border, most probably well south of Quetta (Jacobabad and Sibi) or south west of Quetta (between Kharan and Kalat). Area north of Quetta will be well within Taliban reach as well as being die-hard Jamiat - i - Ulema Islam country, JUI (F) and JUI (S) being the country cousins of the Taliban. The good news is that both the spiritual leaders with maximum nuisance value, Maulana Fazal ur Rehman, JUI (F) and Maulana Samiul Haq, JUI (S) seem to be aligning themselves to the government bandwagon.

Pakistan has categorically said that it will not commit its forces beyond its borders. In any case, we will have to provide troops for the outer defensive perimeter for the forward bases as well as mobile covering troops between the border and those bases. Peshawar must be ruled out as a possible base, it has no “stand-off” distance from populated areas but Quetta can be used. The hard flat ground in many areas of South-west Balochistan can be easily and quickly prepared for operations of transport aircraft bringing in troops to marry up helicopters already in position.

Damage control internally is needed to keep militant pro-Afghan elements in check. The President’s speech has gone down well, even though he speaks far better extempore than from a prepared text, he made some very telling points by giving examples of our Prophet Muhammad’s (PBUH) patience in making peace with Jews. One of the reasons for deterioration of law and order is the economic deprivation born mainly out of western sanctions. Economic revival is the key to domestically being able to cope with our local problems; quick pragmatic decisions have to be taken by the US, European Union countries and Japan. Time is of the essence! Musharraf has risked everything for doing the right thing without delay, how fast will the western nations respond by shoring up his position diplomatically, militarily and economically? And while at it, the Bush Administration could also analyze the root cause of fundamentalism in this very vital area; Kashmir is something that needs their priority attention for an amicable and lasting solution.


The views, opinion and recommendations expressed in the articles published in this magazine are entirely that of the author of that particular article, this magazine serves only as a neutral platform for healthy debate where contrary thoughts in print are considered an important cornerstone of the freedom of expression enshrined as the essence of democracy.

Pathfinder Fountain, Clifton, KARACHI, PAKISTAN Tel 021-5861637, 5863920, Fax 021-5863923 Telex 28843 PFGRP PK
*LAHORE Tel 042-6360237, 5760244 Fax 042-6360236 *PESHAWAR Tel 091-271691, 272513 Fax 0351-290038 *ISLAMABAD Tel 051-826674, 823851 Fax 0351-221570 *QUETTA Tel 081-448836 Fax 081-448836 *HYDERABAD Tel 0221-866700 *MULTAN Tel 061-544004, 581832 Fax 061-581839 *SIALKOT Tel 0432-265413 *SUKKUR Tel 071-30425 *NOWSHERA Tel 05231-3571 *GUJRAT Tel 04331-524156 *SAHIWAL Tel 0441-66387 *FAISALABAD Tel 041-760430 *RAHIMYAR KHAN Tel 0731-73787 *RAWALPINDI Tel 051-518028, 565325, Fax 0351-260715 *ABBOTTABAD Tel 05921-33870

E-Mail Address: defjrnl@pathfinder.com.pk   Internet Address: http://www.defencejournal.com

                                                            backhome