Dear
Sir
I commend the Defence Journal for being a forum
for discussion of Pakistan's military history and
defence matters etc.
This refers to the article “Is a Kashmir
Solution in the Offing” by Air Commodore Jamal
Hussain (Retired).
The writer states that “The accession of
the state of Jammu and Kashmir to India by the Maharaja
in 1948 whether willingly or under duress was morally
and legally wrong and was in complete violation
of the very concept that led to the partition of
Indian Sub-Continent into India and Pakistan”.
This assertion is historically incorrect. (1) The
Maharaja signed the instrument of accession not
in 1948 as the writer asserts but on October 26,
1947. (2) More serious is the writers second assertion
that the accession of the Maharaja “was in
complete violation of the very concept that led
to the partition of Indian Sub-Continent into India
and Pakistan”.
The hard fact of the whole affair is as following:-....more