Dear Readers,
It is my sad duty to inform our valued
readers of the sad demise of Capt Jilani, one of our
estimated and prolific writers. The cover story on
him is self-explanatory, for me it is a deep personal
loss. He was a very good man, and a very accomplished
one at that. I wonder if the cover story can really
do justice to him. While not covered in this month’s
DJ, the growing problem in the world due to the unnecessary
printing of the Prophet’s (PBUH) caricatures
may go out of hand. One hopes better sense will prevail.
With respect to the Australian wheat that was rejected
by DG PASSCO, Maj Gen Fahim Akhtar Khan, a self-explanatory
article has been included for the benefit of readers
entitled “THE AUSTRALIAN WHEAT SCAM”.
This year DAVOS was again very interesting, the President
of Pakistan remained the center of universal attraction.
This took some doing in a gathering of the world elite.
I am taking the liberty of reproducing my article
entitled “THE DAVOS FEELING” for the benefit
of readers.
One can describe the Davos feeling
till Kingdom Come, you cannot capture it in words
(or video) for others. A truly unique gathering of
Heads of State and Government, senior ministers (mainly
of finance and commerce), the Annual Meeting of the
World Economic Forum (WEF) includes world renowned
academics and intellectuals (including quite a few
Nobel Prize winners), nearly a 1000 of the major companies
of the world represented by their Chief Executives,
200 or so of the topmost media personalities of the
world (both print and electronics) and selected non-governmental
organizations (NGOs). The 2006 highlight was an address
by former US President Clinton. Among the Heads of
State, Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, Nigerian
President Obasanjo, German President Angela Merkel,
etc. Among the celebrities, Muhammad Ali and Shabana
Azmi received Crystal Awards in recognition of excellence
in their respective fields. I was extremely impressed
by the natural humility and grace of Shabana Azmi.
Admiring her as a beautiful and outstanding actress
is one thing, her contribution to the social sector
is really amazing, but to have her mix without any
shred of arrogance was really captivating. One wishes
there are more like her, the world is a better place
because of people like Shabana Azmi.
The focus this year was on the two
emerging economic powers, China and India, and their
present and possible future interaction with the countries
of the world, and their own region in particular.
Statistics cannot really describe the dynamism of
a people that attracted US$ 60 billion in foreign
direct investment (FDI) in 2005, compare it in 2005
to the other country that has done really well India,
which attracted US$ 6 billion. China does not have
to really sell itself to the world, and it doesn’t,
yet its rapid economic growth continues to be the
first country of choice of investment. It is unfair
to compare China to India, which has recently found
its feet in the world of investment but is now among
the countries of preference for investment. India
this year went all out to demonstrate its economic
dynamism, and even though PM Manmohan Singh was not
there, Ministers like Chidambram, Kamal Nath, etc
were quite prominent in their walkaround among potential
investors, almost all of whom were present in Davos.
Starting with an “Incredible India” media
campaign, including posters at Zurich airport on the
road to Davos, on many vehicles and buildings, etc
I believe that the Confederation of India Industry
(CII) had a budget of US$ 3 million, it showed, down
to the thunderous grand finale of a foot stamping
thrilling dance and musical presentation for the Gala
Soiree. Not one penny was contributed by the government
or the companies in the public sector, it was a pure
commercial enterprise put together by the private
sector both in money and content. All those who did
it for their country deserve congratulations, and
it is a matter of pride and a source of inspiration
for all other South Asians, maybe we can emulate them
in future, we have a common objective to wipe out
poverty and deprivation from one of the most poverty
stricken regions in the world.
India was upstaged to some degree
in the political arena by President Musharraf’s
dominating presence in Davos. He had a frenetic schedule
of media conferences, sessions, bi-lateral meetings,
lunches with business leaders and a truly mixed gathering
of nearly 250 business leaders, academics, media persons
etc who braved the cold and falling snow at 7:00 of
a Friday morning for a breakfast session. Throughout
Gen Musharraf was in his element, and took pains (and
difficult questions) to give Pakistan’s viewpoint
on the geo-political situation, counter-terrorism,
economics, etc. At one Session he went from table
to table talking to the participants. As a Pakistani
it was good to hear adulatory remarks about a Pakistani
leader from hard-bitten persona who don’t give
their praise easily. He made no apologies for his
being a uniformed person, in fact he contained any
criticism by openly stating why it was necessary for
Pakistan to progress to democracy in a phased manner.
Someone asked him about a successor, he disarmed the
crowd by saying, to quote “this is not a monarchy,
when I am gone the system will select a successor”.
I must congratulate Ambassador Masood Khan and the
Pakistan Mission Staff at Geneva. Being a Davos veteran
of over a dozen years, one is rather skeptical about
Foreign Office gnomes who have been mostly boorish
and arrogant in a place where one has to mix well.
This year the Pakistan foreign mission was extremely
pro-active, the credit must go to Masood Khan. Those
(nearly 250) who came for “Breakfast at Davos”,
at 7 am at the Hotel Steigenberger with the President
included personalities like Khalid Abdullah Janahi
(Shamil Bank of Bahrain), Khalid Alireza (Xenel/Saudi
Cable Company), Rahul Bajaj (Bajaj Auto of India),
Philip Bowring (International Herald Tribune, Hong
Kong) Peter Eigen (Transparency International, Germany),
Ann M. Florin (The Brookings Institution, USA), Adi
B. Godrej (Godrej Industries Ltd, India), Dhruv Sawhney
(Triveni Engineering & Industries Ltd, India),
Katherine Marshall (World Bank, USA), Imam Feisal
Abdul Rauf (Cordoba Initiative, USA), Sir Martin Sorrel
(WPP, USA), Joseph Stiglitz (Columbia University,
USA), Strobe Talbott (The Brookings Institution, USA),
Mr Michael Useem (The Wharton School, University of
Pennsylvania, USA) etc.
A few Pakistanis are WEF members,
among them Hussain Dawood, Chairman Dawood Group,
Tariq Karmani, Chairman PIA, Jalees Ahmed Siddiqi,
MD PSO, Zakir Mahmood, President HBL, Lawyers Tafazzul
Rizvi and bureaucrat-turned social worker Tasneem
A. Siddiqui, circulated very well. Former PML (N)
Minister Sartaj Aziz was invited in his personal capacity
and contributed to a number of sessions, it was good
to see him get recognition of his own volition. Ministers
Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri, Jehangir Tareen, Awais Leghari
(who is also a WEF Young Global Leader), Ms Sumaira
Malik and Hina Rabbani Khar circulated well, they
need to mix more among the Annual Meeting participants,
staying back even when the President goes away. It
was wonderful to see a Pakistan hold the world stage
in commerce in the form of Dubai-based Arif Naqvi,
easily mixing among world business heavyweights in
his own right as a genuine article. We have to somehow
get more Pakistani business people to Davos, this
is a networking opportunity that must be availed if
Pakistan is to attract foreign direct investment (FDI)
in any volume that matters. If FDI is US$ 6 billion
for India in 2005, I have no doubt it will be close
to US$ 10 billion in 2006. The boost that India gets
because of Davos, and also because it is the initiative
of the private sector with a lot of encouragement
from the government.
Global Agenda produced a wonderful
Pakistan Supplement, congratulations are in order
to the whole publishing team. It was hard work, and
the entire credit in Pakistan must go to Omer Ayub
Khan, Minister of State for Finance, son of the Former
Speaker Gohar Ayub Khan and grandson of the man who
brought industrialization to Pakistan, President and
Field Marshal Muhammad Ayub Khan. This young man put
his heart and soul in the success of this Supplement,
and one most congratulate him in staying the course
in ensuring that the Supplement happened despite the
fact that he got only lip-service support from those
who matter, for reasons of their own. The sad part
is that those who spend millions and millions of public
money just to get the attention of the President had
to be persuaded both in the public and private sector
to make their contributions. The Supplement was a
good back-drop to the President’s presence,
he was not accompanied by any media men, and unlike
others he does not need one. If you have quality and
stature it shows. You don’t have to employ full
time PR people churning out propaganda, the world
quickly discovers who is a person of substance and
who is not. Riding on PR you can get to a pinnacle,
you will sooner or later be found out for what you
are. For the sake of this country we must keep sending
leaders regularly to Davos who are committed to the
country and not to themselves. Pervez Musharraf scores
heavily in Davos because he roots for Pakistan with
his heart and soul, and it shows.
M.
Ikram Sehgal